Changes between Version 16 and Version 20 of Ticket #14346


Ignore:
Timestamp:
04/11/13 10:07:05 (7 years ago)
Author:
Snark
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #14346 – Description

    v16 v20  
    1 The pari package has 15 patches, there are various problems with these:
    2  1. patches ..... should have been proposed upstream but haven't been reported.
    3  1. patch ..... breaks the ABI of the function ......(). It will cause problems when upgrading to the next PARI version because ........
    4  1. `polred.patch` in lines ... - ... of file ...... puts new developments in a package, which should instead be moved to the Sage library.
     1This spkg has 15 patches, with the following :
     2 1. get_ld.patch: author known, pure packaging - GOOD
     3 2. get_tests.patch: author known, pure packaging - GOOD
     4 3. get_config_options.patch: author known, upstream-worthy, no comment says it was forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     5 4. get_fltk.patch: author known, upstream-worthy, no comment says it was forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     6 5. get_X11.patch: author known, upstream-worthy, no comment says it was forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     7 6. get_dlcflags.patch: author known, upstream-worthy, a comment says upstream has a partial fix but doesn't say that better patch has been forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     8 7. install_doc_no_make.patch: author known, pure packaging - GOOD
     9 8. perl_path.patch: author known, pure packaging - GOOD
     10 9. cygwin_dll_a.patch: author known, pure packaging - GOOD
     11 10. KERNELCFLAGS.patch: author unknown, you have to look at a bug report to see who the author is and that it was forwarded upstream - HALF-GOOD
     12 11. src/kernel/gmp/mp.c: author unknown, upstream-worthy, no comment says it was forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     13 12. GCC_PR49330.patch: author unknown, upstream-worthy, no comment says it was forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     14 13. trac_13902_determinant.patch: author unknown, upstream backport, hopefully not too modified - GOOD?
     15 14. galoisanalysis_p4.patch: author unknown, upstream-worthy, no comment says it was forwarded, which probably means it wasn't - BAD
     16 15. polred.patch: author unknown, upstream backport + added function -- the upstream backport is ok, adding a new function isn't [that should be done in the sage library] - BAD