Opened 7 years ago

Last modified 3 years ago

#12529 new defect

libsingular reduces polynomials incompletely

Reported by: SimonKing Owned by: malb
Priority: critical Milestone: sage-6.4
Component: commutative algebra Keywords: multivariate polynomial reduction
Cc: malb Merged in:
Authors: Reviewers:
Report Upstream: N/A Work issues:
Branch: Commit:
Dependencies: Stopgaps: todo

Description

On sage-support, Oleksandr Kazymyrov reported the following:

sage: bits=3
sage:
sage: k=GF(2^bits,'a')
sage: P=PolynomialRing(k,1+bits+bits+bits-1+(1<<bits),['y'] +
['a{0}'.format(g) for g in xrange(bits)] + ['b{0}'.format(g) for g in
xrange(bits)] + ['c{0}'.format(g) for g in xrange(1,bits)] +
['p{0}'.format(g) for g in xrange(1<<bits)])
sage:
sage: A1=sum([P('(a{0})*y^{0}'.format(g)) for g in xrange(bits)])
sage: A2=sum([P('(b{0})*y^{0}'.format(g)) for g in xrange(bits)])
sage: A3=sum([P('(c{0})*y^{0}'.format(g)) for g in xrange(1,bits)])
sage: pol = sum([P('(p{0})*y^{0}'.format(g)) for g in xrange(1<<bits)])
sage: pol=pol.subs({P("y"):A2})
sage: pol=A1.subs({P("y"):pol})
sage: pol=pol+A3
sage: pol.mod(P("y^{0}+y".format(1<<bits))) 
y^7*a2*b1^14*p7^2 + y^7*a2*b2^14*p7^2 + y^10*a2*b1^10*p5^2 + y^8*a2*b0^4*b1^8*p6^2 + y^8*a2*b0^8*b2^4*p6^2 + y^14*a1*b2^7*p7 + y^6*a2*b0^8*b1^6*p7^2 + y^6*a2*b1^8*b2^6*p7^2 + y^6*a2*b0^2*b1^4*b2^8*p7^2 + y^6*a2*b0^4*b2^10*p7^2 + y^9*a2*b0^2*b2^8*p5^2 + y^13*a1*b1*b2^6*p7 + y^5*a2*b0^2*b1^12*p7^2 + y^5*a2*b0^4*b1^8*b2^2*p7^2 + y^5*a2*b0^8*b2^6*p7^2 + y^5*a2*b1^2*b2^12*p7^2 + y^12*a2*b2^6*p3^2 + y^8*a2*b0^2*b1^8*p5^2 + y^6*a2*b1^4*b2^8*p6^2 + y^12*a1*b1^2*b2^5*p7 + y^12*a1*b0*b2^6*p7 + y^4*a2*b0^10*b1^4*p7^2 + y^4*a2*b0^12*b2^2*p7^2 + y^4*a2*b1^10*b2^4*p7^2 + y^4*a2*b0^4*b1^2*b2^8*p7^2 + y^9*a2*b2^8*p4^2 + y^12*a1*b2^6*p6 + y^5*a2*b1^12*p6^2 + y^11*a1*b1^3*b2^4*p7 + y^3*a2*b0^4*b1^10*p7^2 + y^3*a2*b0^8*b1^2*b2^4*p7^2 + y^3*a2*b1^4*b2^10*p7^2 + y^3*a2*b0^2*b2^12*p7^2 + y^10*a2*b1^2*b2^4*p3^2 + y^8*a2*b1^8*p4^2 + y^6*a2*b2^10*p5^2 + y^4*a2*b0^8*b1^4*p6^2 + y^10*a1*b1^4*b2^3*p7 + y^10*a1*b0*b1^2*b2^4*p7 + y^10*a1*b0^2*b2^5*p7 + y^2*a2*b0^12*b1^2*p7^2 + y^2*a2*b1^12*b2^2*p7^2 + y^2*a2*b0^2*b1^8*b2^4*p7^2 + y^2*a2*b0^6*b2^8*p7^2 + y^5*a2*b1^8*b2^2*p5^2 + y^10*a1*b1^2*b2^4*p6 + y^3*a2*b2^12*p6^2 + y^9*a1*b1^5*b2^2*p7 + y^9*a1*b0^2*b1*b2^4*p7 + y*a2*b0^6*b1^8*p7^2 + y*a2*b0^8*b1^4*b2^2*p7^2 + y*a2*b0^10*b2^4*p7^2 + y*a2*b1^6*b2^8*p7^2 + y^8*a2*b1^4*b2^2*p3^2 + y^8*a2*b0^2*b2^4*p3^2 + y^10*a1*b2^5*p5 + y^4*a2*b0^8*b2^2*p5^2 + y^4*a2*b1^2*b2^8*p5^2 + y^2*a2*b1^8*b2^4*p6^2 + y^2*a2*b0^4*b2^8*p6^2 + y^8*a1*b1^6*b2*p7 + y^8*a1*b0*b1^4*b2^2*p7 + y^8*a1*b0^3*b2^4*p7 + a2*b0^14*p7^2 + y^9*a1*b1*b2^4*p5 + y^8*a1*b1^4*b2^2*p6 + y^8*a1*b0^2*b2^4*p6 + y^7*a1*b1^7*p7 + y^8*a2*b2^4*p2^2 + y^6*a2*b1^6*p3^2 + y^8*a1*b0*b2^4*p5 + y^2*a2*b0^8*b1^2*p5^2 + a2*b0^12*p6^2 + y^6*a1*b0*b1^6*p7 + y^6*a1*b0^2*b1^4*b2*p7 + y^6*a1*b0^4*b2^3*p7 + y^8*a1*b2^4*p4 + y^6*a1*b1^6*p6 + y^5*a1*b0^2*b1^5*p7 + y^5*a1*b0^4*b1*b2^2*p7 + y^4*a2*b0^2*b1^4*p3^2 + y^4*a2*b0^4*b2^2*p3^2 + y^6*a1*b1^4*b2*p5 + a2*b0^10*p5^2 + y^4*a1*b0^3*b1^4*p7 + y^4*a1*b0^4*b1^2*b2*p7 + y^4*a1*b0^5*b2^2*p7 + y^5*a1*b1^5*p5 + y^4*a1*b0^2*b1^4*p6 + y^4*a1*b0^4*b2^2*p6 + y^3*a1*b0^4*b1^3*p7 + y^4*a2*b1^4*p2^2 + y^6*a1*b2^3*p3 + y^2*a2*b0^4*b1^2*p3^2 + a2*b0^8*p4^2 + y^4*a1*b0*b1^4*p5 + y^2*a1*b0^5*b1^2*p7 + y^2*a1*b0^6*b2*p7 + y^5*a1*b1*b2^2*p3 + y^4*a1*b1^4*p4 + y^2*a1*b0^4*b1^2*p6 + y*a1*b0^6*b1*p7 + y^4*a2*b2^2*p1^2 + y^4*a1*b1^2*b2*p3 + y^4*a1*b0*b2^2*p3 + a2*b0^6*p3^2 + y^2*a1*b0^4*b2*p5 + a1*b0^7*p7 + y^4*a1*b2^2*p2 + y^3*a1*b1^3*p3 + y*a1*b0^4*b1*p5 + a1*b0^6*p6 + y^2*a2*b1^2*p1^2 + a2*b0^4*p2^2 + y^2*a1*b0*b1^2*p3 + y^2*a1*b0^2*b2*p3 + a1*b0^5*p5 + y^2*a1*b1^2*p2 + y*a1*b0^2*b1*p3 + a1*b0^4*p4 + y^2*a1*b2*p1 + a2*b0^2*p1^2 + a1*b0^3*p3 + y*a1*b1*p1 + a1*b0^2*p2 + y^2*c2 + a2*p0^2 + a1*b0*p1 + y*c1 + a1*p0 + a0

The mod operation does not reduce all terms:

sage: pol.mod(P("y^{0}+y".format(1<<bits))).monomials()[3]
y^8*a2*b0^4*b1^8*p6^2
sage: pol.mod(P("y^{0}+y".format(1<<bits))).monomials()[2]
y^10*a2*b1^10*p5^2

However, a reduction of the single terms works:

sage: pol.mod(P("y^{0}+y".format(1<<bits))).monomials()[2].mod(P("y^{0}+y".format(1<<bits)))
y^3*a2*b1^10*p5^2

Note that Singular does the reduction right:

sage: singular(pol).NF(singular(P.ideal(P("y^{0}+y".format(1<<bits)))).std())
y^7*a2*b1^14*p7^2+y^7*a2*b2^14*p7^2+y^6*a2*b0^8*b1^6*p7^2+y^6*a2*b1^8*b2^6*p7^2+y^6*a2*b0^2*b1^4*b2^8*p7^2+y^6*a2*b0^4*b2^10*p7^2+y^5*a2*b0^2*b1^12*p7^2+y^5*a2*b0^4*b1^8*b2^2*p7^2+y^5*a2*b0^8*b2^6*p7^2+y^5*a2*b1^2*b2^12*p7^2+y^6*a2*b1^4*b2^8*p6^2+y^4*a2*b0^10*b1^4*p7^2+y^4*a2*b0^12*b2^2*p7^2+y^4*a2*b1^10*b2^4*p7^2+y^4*a2*b0^4*b1^2*b2^8*p7^2+y^5*a2*b1^12*p6^2+y^3*a2*b0^4*b1^10*p7^2+y^3*a2*b0^8*b1^2*b2^4*p7^2+y^3*a2*b1^4*b2^10*p7^2+y^3*a2*b0^2*b2^12*p7^2+y^6*a2*b2^10*p5^2+y^4*a2*b0^8*b1^4*p6^2+y^2*a2*b0^12*b1^2*p7^2+y^2*a2*b1^12*b2^2*p7^2+y^2*a2*b0^2*b1^8*b2^4*p7^2+y^2*a2*b0^6*b2^8*p7^2+y^5*a2*b1^8*b2^2*p5^2+y^3*a2*b2^12*p6^2+y*a2*b0^6*b1^8*p7^2+y*a2*b0^8*b1^4*b2^2*p7^2+y*a2*b0^10*b2^4*p7^2+y*a2*b1^6*b2^8*p7^2+y^4*a2*b0^8*b2^2*p5^2+y^4*a2*b1^2*b2^8*p5^2+y^2*a2*b1^8*b2^4*p6^2+y^2*a2*b0^4*b2^8*p6^2+a2*b0^14*p7^2+y^3*a2*b1^10*p5^2+y*a2*b0^4*b1^8*p6^2+y*a2*b0^8*b2^4*p6^2+y^7*a1*b1^7*p7+y^7*a1*b2^7*p7+y^6*a2*b1^6*p3^2+y^2*a2*b0^8*b1^2*p5^2+y^2*a2*b0^2*b2^8*p5^2+a2*b0^12*p6^2+y^6*a1*b0*b1^6*p7+y^6*a1*b0^2*b1^4*b2*p7+y^6*a1*b0^4*b2^3*p7+y^6*a1*b1*b2^6*p7+y^5*a2*b2^6*p3^2+y*a2*b0^2*b1^8*p5^2+y^6*a1*b1^6*p6+y^5*a1*b0^2*b1^5*p7+y^5*a1*b0^4*b1*b2^2*p7+y^5*a1*b1^2*b2^5*p7+y^5*a1*b0*b2^6*p7+y^4*a2*b0^2*b1^4*p3^2+y^4*a2*b0^4*b2^2*p3^2+y^2*a2*b2^8*p4^2+y^6*a1*b1^4*b2*p5+a2*b0^10*p5^2+y^5*a1*b2^6*p6+y^4*a1*b0^3*b1^4*p7+y^4*a1*b0^4*b1^2*b2*p7+y^4*a1*b0^5*b2^2*p7+y^4*a1*b1^3*b2^4*p7+y^3*a2*b1^2*b2^4*p3^2+y*a2*b1^8*p4^2+y^5*a1*b1^5*p5+y^4*a1*b0^2*b1^4*p6+y^4*a1*b0^4*b2^2*p6+y^3*a1*b0^4*b1^3*p7+y^3*a1*b1^4*b2^3*p7+y^3*a1*b0*b1^2*b2^4*p7+y^3*a1*b0^2*b2^5*p7+y^4*a2*b1^4*p2^2+y^6*a1*b2^3*p3+y^2*a2*b0^4*b1^2*p3^2+a2*b0^8*p4^2+y^4*a1*b0*b1^4*p5+y^3*a1*b1^2*b2^4*p6+y^2*a1*b0^5*b1^2*p7+y^2*a1*b0^6*b2*p7+y^2*a1*b1^5*b2^2*p7+y^2*a1*b0^2*b1*b2^4*p7+y^5*a1*b1*b2^2*p3+y*a2*b1^4*b2^2*p3^2+y*a2*b0^2*b2^4*p3^2+y^4*a1*b1^4*p4+y^3*a1*b2^5*p5+y^2*a1*b0^4*b1^2*p6+y*a1*b0^6*b1*p7+y*a1*b1^6*b2*p7+y*a1*b0*b1^4*b2^2*p7+y*a1*b0^3*b2^4*p7+y^4*a2*b2^2*p1^2+y^4*a1*b1^2*b2*p3+y^4*a1*b0*b2^2*p3+a2*b0^6*p3^2+y^2*a1*b0^4*b2*p5+y^2*a1*b1*b2^4*p5+y*a1*b1^4*b2^2*p6+y*a1*b0^2*b2^4*p6+a1*b0^7*p7+y^4*a1*b2^2*p2+y*a2*b2^4*p2^2+y^3*a1*b1^3*p3+y*a1*b0^4*b1*p5+y*a1*b0*b2^4*p5+a1*b0^6*p6+y^2*a2*b1^2*p1^2+a2*b0^4*p2^2+y^2*a1*b0*b1^2*p3+y^2*a1*b0^2*b2*p3+y*a1*b2^4*p4+a1*b0^5*p5+y^2*a1*b1^2*p2+y*a1*b0^2*b1*p3+a1*b0^4*p4+y^2*a1*b2*p1+a2*b0^2*p1^2+a1*b0^3*p3+y*a1*b1*p1+a1*b0^2*p2+y^2*c2+a2*p0^2+a1*b0*p1+y*c1+a1*p0+a0

So, it seems to me that the problem is in libsingular, not in Singular.

I guess the reduction is supposed to reduce the tail as well - if tail reduction is not done by default, then the doc should mention it.

I think those basic arithmetic failures generally are blockers.

Change History (6)

comment:1 Changed 7 years ago by jdemeyer

  • Priority changed from blocker to critical

I don't believe all basic arithmetic failures should be blockers, and it's dubious that this issue is even about "basic" arithmetic.

comment:2 Changed 6 years ago by jdemeyer

  • Milestone changed from sage-5.11 to sage-5.12

comment:3 Changed 5 years ago by vbraun_spam

  • Milestone changed from sage-6.1 to sage-6.2

comment:4 Changed 5 years ago by vbraun_spam

  • Milestone changed from sage-6.2 to sage-6.3

comment:5 Changed 5 years ago by vbraun_spam

  • Milestone changed from sage-6.3 to sage-6.4

comment:6 Changed 3 years ago by jakobkroeker

  • Stopgaps set to todo
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.